From Amateur to Professional
The path to becoming a professional songwriter is never as clean-cut as we’d like it to be. If only there were ads in the classifieds “writer needed for top pop act,” with a phone number and an address to send a resume, it would be more obvious to know where to start. For me, the transition from hobbyist to professional writer was a bit like wandering through the woods and then suddenly stepping out into the clearing. I didn’t know how far down the path I had tread until I found myself already at my destination.
The trouble with success like anything in life, is that it’s not typically a steady upwards curve. There are months or years when even professional songwriters don’t get paid for their craft, being in-between deals or waiting for royalties to trickle in, and so in the most realistic sense, professional is a just a matter of experience and a way of doing business.
So what are some of the activities or elements that transition a hobby songwriter to a professional? I’ll give you my two cents, and you can add your own as you look back into the woods from your own clearing.
The first activity that makes the change is writing. It seems obvious, but it’s amazing how easy it can be to get distracted or just plain too busy, and stop writing regularly to develop our craft. Writing songs can certainly be a gift, and with that gift each of us brings a certain style and inspiration. But like any other skill, it takes dedication to learn to direct our inspiration to consistently achieve the results we want. That’s the important word here, consistency. Professional writers don’t just write one great song every 6 months. They write 10 good ones every 3 months, and if we’re lucky, 2 or 3 of those stand out as great songs.
I can’t stress enough the importance of writing, even when you don’t feel inspired. If you’re going for a publishing deal, for example, the company expects you to continuously put out more material. That’s how you stay relevant and current to the industry. Even as an artist writing for yourself or for others, if the last song you wrote and recorded was 6 months ago, you could be 6 months behind the trend…not to mention everyone you’ve played the song for has begun to forget you’re still around. Fans need to be reminded too. With so much new music coming out that is so accessible, we can’t go into hiding for too long before we’re simply out of mind as well as out of sight.
All the other activities, from networking to performing, getting to know names in the industry, gaining studio and recording experience, co-writing, following leads to meetings with industry gate-keepers, and so on are secondary. Learning how to carry ourselves in a meeting such as how many songs to play and how to accept criticism and compliments are certainly important, but without the activity of writing, we hardly get the chance to practice those skills.
There are hundreds of thousands of people who write songs and fancy themselves songwriters. What makes the difference between a hobbyist and a professional is how aware the write is of his/her own shortcomings and potentials. It’s not how many songs we get recorded or how much money we make (artists as famous for not being recognized and appreciated until they’re dead). It’s how much we enjoy the craft that enables us to survive just about anything along the way.
If you’re writing a few times a week and would like to step up your game in other areas of the business, I encourage you to follow some of the steps I’ve outlined in my previous blogs entitled ‘While You Are Writing.’ If you have specific questions about a crossroads you’ve reached in your career, please feel free to submit your comments in response to this blog. I’d be glad to take a stab at brainstorming with you for your next big career step.
Sincerely,
Andrea Stolpe

| 




Hello,
Could you comment on services such as Taxi? I’m debating whether or not to join, and would love to get your opinion. Also, do have any thoughts on good web sites for songwriters? Myspace is obviously decent for performers, but what about a site for non-performers, where the emphasis is really on the songs. Last, what are some info sources for finding A&R folks?
As always, thanks for the blog. Really good stuff.
Jeff (www.cerebellumblues.com)
I have gotten a lot from your blog. I am currently stationed in Iraq, and want to be productive with my spare time here. The day I read that I should be writing a song or so a week, I managed to finish a song. Of course that has been three weeks, but I am at least doing some writing, either music or words, almost every day. (As you can understand, I get a little busy from time to time.) I especially took to heart your comments about writing more personally, writing a song about missing my daughter’s birthday while over here. I will be getting your book as soon as I am able.
Thanks for the million-dollar’s worth of advice via your blog. I’ve been approaching the business as an artist (still am, in fact) with some success in the past, but ultimately, I want to write for more folks than just myself. I’ve been to several workshops with Barbara Cloyd, NSAI, SGA, TSA…you name it and they’ve all been helpful in refining my craft. I’m also hoping that the retreat to Wyoming with Skip Ewing & Co. will add to my education in August.
I’ve been working with Trish Yearwood’s Band Leader Johnny Garcia and we’re in the studio this coming Monday cutting my next record. I’ve been in contact with Joe Leathers and George Ducas and I’m trying to develop my “circle” of friends and influence so that it can help me facilitate my career as a songwriter. As a result, some of their collaborations will end up on this project.
I haven’t been very persistent as a writer who’s searching for a publishing deal, but ultimately that’s what I want to do. I’ve had some great reviews from folks like Barbara and other folks I’ve met and played for at the Bluebird and the other open mic nights around town…and not to mention my fan base in the Southwest U.S.A. I guess I’m just looking for some more advice…a hint…a nugget of wisdom that can give me some more direction and inspiration as I travel down this road. I know that’s pretty general and broad, but it coming from someone who’s in the game, would mean a lot to me.
Thanks for your time and consideration. If you get a chance, you can listen to some of my solo efforts at myspace.com/jrcastillo and myspace.com/jrcastilloandunwound. I look forward to hearing from you. Again, thanks for the blogs!!!
J.R. Castillo
361.362.5754
Hi
I’ve been writing from about 8 years old. I really want to use my talent in the best for me and my two doughters. I am disabled. I’m working but its not enough for us to live on our own. I am devorced for about 9 years now, and God really take good care of us thrue this difficult years. He is also the creator of my talent. My doughter of 13 Years old also write her own songs with the sound in her mind how it should sound. Where can we go to take our songs to stage to be sing in the open? We love writing and its part of us thru every day.
Hi Jeff,
I wrote a blog about Taxi and song contests several months ago. You might check it out, then ask around to gather other opinions. Most industry folks from music supervisors, label execs, publishers, and artists I have contact with agree that there is no substitute for personal relationships and expanding our network of fans. In this manner, TAXI and song contests aren’t much help.
Websites for songwriters - that’s a question I haven’t got an answer to. However, I’d be glad to do some searching and throw in my 2 cents. Look for future blogs on that.
Finally, sources for finding A&R. I assume you’re looking for a record deal. My advice is to work on building your fan base by playing shows and talking about your music as much as possible. Meet and perform with other musicians in the industry, co-write, and immerse yourself in the industry where you live. Take advantage of ASCAP and BMI events and others such as those put on by the Association of Independent Music Publishers.
Just get involved. You’ll meet people that are going to be instrumental in getting you to the next rung on the ladder, A&R or otherwise.
Good luck,
Andrea
Brad,
I’m happy to hear that you are aiming for a song a week. The song about missing your daughter’s birthday sounds like a great start. Write what you know - the truth will shine through and connect with the very heart and soul of your listeners.
Andrea
Hi Andrea,
i really enjoy reading your blogs. i have been working on my songwriting craft for a number of years and have developed a really good sound and flow. i have everything now apart from someone to listen to my stuff. i’m really unsure with where to go to next and who to trust out there. i know that i have a talent and something to share. any thoughts would be appreciated.
Scott
The commonality between all our comments here seems to be finding folks to listen to our songs. Instead of generalizing in a response to your comments, I’ll write a blog about some concrete steps we can take towards that goal. Hang tight -
Andrea
Leave a Comment