Music and Relationships
Musicians aren’t exactly famous for their ability to handle relationships well. The stereotype is that our art comes first, and that there is always a part of ourselves we withhold from our loved ones as we’re devoted to another muse. That may be true for some, but perhaps it’s impossible to distinguish whether it’s a product of our personalities and choices rather than the fact that we have a musical gene weaving through our DNA.
Recently a fellow songwriter shared with me a difficult situation with his wife resulting from a seemingly insignificant performance of a popular song. The song brought up some sensitive issues, and in doing so, created a rift within the most important relationship in his life. As songwriters and artists, it’s only natural we sing and write about issues close to home. By the very act of connecting with our audience, we focus on what provokes thought and causes emotion. We can even bring to life an experience that was not our own, and write it with such sensitivity, such detail, that it becomes real once more in the span of that 3 and half minutes.
I’ve personally performed songs I’ve written where after the performance, several audience members came to me with concern for my well-being. No, I wasn’t suicidal, but rather digging deep into the difficulties of what matters most to us in life- our relationships. Some songs are just more powerful written from first person perspective. In this case, taking a side-line view of divorce using he/she said language just wouldn’t cut it. I had to expose every fiber in my body to the sting, the hurt, the desperation and the shame of what it would feel like to find myself at the end of that rope. We’ve all been in similar situations or felt empathy for others in those situations, so I’m not about to pretend that I’m safely on the sidelines of every song I write. I’m saying that in order to write songs that matter, sometimes I’ve got to reveal my own vulnerability by personalizing the issues that affect us all.
I hope that those listening to my songs feel comforted and less alone. The few that decide all my song lyrics foreshadow the dissolving of my closest relationships are missing the point. For those close to me, a good sit-down discussion about where the song came from and why I chose to write it can be a great idea. I don’t know about you, but often my songs reveal to me things I’ve been tossing around in my head before I know I’ve been tossing them around. In a sense, I guess you could say I journal to pitch and rhythm. My songs are an extension of how I look at the world and how I think the world looks at me. Sometimes that’s messy, and sometimes it’s beautiful, but it’s always honest. And that’s all I owe myself or anybody else.

| 




I am in the middle of a separation, moving towards divorce. The difficulty is that I don’t want this relationship to end. What has been interesting to me is playing songs that have been wrapped up in this relationship - from its start to now. Writing and playing them has been at once both cathartic and painful - for both of us.
There is a lifetime in those songs - not all of which are necessarily auto-biographical - but elements of your life slip in to songs in both subtle and obvious ways. The listener may not now the story behind the story - but, if presented right, the emotion will reach the listener and they make that part of their story.
Great post. What I find toughest about relationships and songwriting is that songs are about moments, whereas relationships take place over time. And as a songwriter, I mine the moments, which would be fine, except for the fact that it’s the troubled moments that seem to offer up the best fodder. So my fiance naturally wonders about how good our relationship is, since so many of my songs are about things going south! www.myshirtiscool.com
Hi.
I’m nosy and would really love to hear which song it was your friend performed that got him in trouble with his other half?
Personally Im lucky because my hubby totally understands my poetic flights of fancy.
I agree with that powerful first-person perspective. And with respect to you having written a song so powerful that friends came up to you after to see if you were o.k. in life, it could come back to the old adage, “Don’t let reality get in the way of a good song.” Sounds like you did your job well.
Thanks for sharing and I look forward to hearing some of your songs.
Jannie
(a songwriting type too.)
Leave a Comment